top of page

Kitchen Design Insights: Why I Choose Durability Over Butcher Block Aesthetics

As an interior designer, I've spent many hours creating spaces that are not only visually appealing but also functional and durable. Among all the rooms in a house, the kitchen stands out as one of the most challenging spaces to design. It's a place where style meets functionality, and where every element must be chosen with careful consideration.


From appliances to colour schemes, every detail plays a critical role in the overall look and feel of the kitchen. But among all these elements, one that often takes centre stage in kitchen design is the counter material.


wooden kitchen counter


What is Butcher Block?

Butcher block, a popular choice for kitchen countertops, is a type of counter material made from straight cuts of wood that are glued together to create a sturdy surface. Its warm, rustic aesthetics can give any kitchen a cosy and inviting atmosphere. Butcher block is often preferred by homeowners who favour wood's natural, organic look and feel. Its classic charm can complement a wide range of kitchen styles, from rustic farmhouse to sleek modern designs.


modern kitchen with butcher block counter

Understanding Butcher Block Basics

Before delving into the advantages and disadvantages of butcher block, it's crucial to grasp some elementary knowledge. When you're in the market for these counters, two primary aspects need your attention: the type of wood used and its construction.


Different Wood Varieties

The specific wood kind greatly influences both aesthetics (colour and grain pattern) and durability (hardness level). There is a wide variety of available choices including birch, walnut, mesquite, bamboo, white oak, hard maple cherry and walnut. Beyond their diverse visual appeal lies their hardness factor which is gauged using the Janka Scale - higher scores indicate harder woods.


For instance, butternut ranks among softer wood types while Brazilian cherry stands out as one of the hardest varieties. Hard maple tends to be a preferred choice for kitchen surfaces due to its mid-range Janka hardness rating of 1450; other woods sharing a similar range include carbonised bamboo, natural bamboo and mahogany. When deciding on whether to opt for hard or softwoods one must contemplate over their intended use of countertop.


Consider this, if you're thinking of using your countertop as a chopping block instead of utilising a cutting board, then softer wood might be the ideal choice. However, if the counter won't come in direct contact with food preparation activities, a harder variant would probably suit better.


wooden kitchen bench with utensils

Construction

The construction aspect of wooden countertops can be divided into four primary categories: edge grain, end grain, face grain and blended.


Edge grain countertops are designed by arranging boards adjacently on their edges which are then fused together so that their sides face upwards. This method is prominently seen in butcher block counters and other areas meant for food preparation because the orientation of the grains doubles up as an effective cutting surface. Many people find this arrangement visually appealing.


End grain countertops consist of numerous small blocks aligned vertically to reveal end grains on top (imagine it like a checkerboard). This pattern works wonderfully for prep zones since its inherent design doesn’t dull sharp knives.


Face grain countertops involve laying out wooden planks flatly such that their broadest section faces upward. While this setup delivers an aesthetically smooth and sophisticated finish to surfaces; it isn't particularly recommended for culinary tasks as knife cuts tend to become visible.



For both edge and face-grain setups, you have options between continuous or jointed strip styles. Continuous strips refer to when timber planks persist through an entire length uninterrupted whereas in jointed versions they are interconnected at intervals across segments.


modern kitchen with wood accents

Pros and Cons of Butcher Block

Like any counter material, butcher block comes with its own set of pros and cons. On the positive side, it offers a warm, natural aesthetic that can add a touch of charm to any kitchen design. It's also relatively easy to install and can be sanded and refinished to remove scratches and signs of wear. It's a natural product which could be an important consideration as well.


I understand the appeal of butcher block. It's warm, inviting, and has a timeless appeal that can enhance any kitchen design. Unlike granite, marble, quartz, and other stones, which can feel cold, wood countertops are warm to the touch. This makes for an inviting surface to eat and entertain.


rustic kitchen island

However, I believe that durability should always be the top priority when choosing a counter material. A kitchen is a high-traffic area that sees a lot of wear and tear. From chopping and slicing to hot pots and pans, your kitchen counter must be able to withstand it all.


Cat on kitchen counter

Choosing a durable counter material can save you a lot of time, money, and headaches in the long run. It means less maintenance, fewer repairs, and a longer lifespan. And while aesthetics are important, they should not be the sole determining factor in your choice of counter material. It's not just about choosing a material that looks good; it's also about selecting a material that can withstand the rigours of daily kitchen use.


Butcher block water damage
Butcher block water damage

Comparing Butcher Block to More Durable Counter Materials

Butcher block requires regular maintenance, including oiling to prevent drying and cracking. It's also prone to scratches, dents, and stains. More importantly, butcher block is not as durable as other counter materials. It's susceptible to water damage and can harbour bacteria if not properly sealed and cleaned.


Butcher block is also sensitive to extreme climates. Rapidly shifting temperatures and dryness can cause the wood to crack, and high humidity can also cause rotting. If you live in a region that gets extremely cold, make sure the kitchen with a butcher block counter is always kept warm. Likewise, if you live in a humid area, consider a dehumidifier in the home to avoid excess moisture in the air.


As a designer, I always prioritise durability in my counter-material choices. I believe that a kitchen counter should not only look good but should also last for many years without requiring constant maintenance or replacement.


I choose durability over aesthetics in kitchen design.

I always recommend choosing more durable kitchen counter materials. They simply are more cost-effective in the long run. While durable materials may have a higher upfront cost, they can save you money over time as they require less maintenance and are less likely to need replacing. Materials like granite and quartz are not only visually stunning, but they are also incredibly durable. They are resistant to scratches, stains, and heat, making them a practical choice for busy kitchens. Stainless steel, while not everyone's aesthetic choice, is another highly durable and practical option.


modern industrial style kitchen

Durable counter materials are also more hygienic. They are easier to clean and are less likely to harbour bacteria, making your kitchen a safer and healthier environment.


Additionally, they can withstand high temperatures, making them a safer choice for kitchens where hot pots and pans are a common sight.


Butcher block heat damage
Butcher block heat damage

Tips for Balancing Aesthetics and Durability in Kitchen Design

Balancing aesthetics and durability in kitchen design doesn't mean compromising style. There are plenty of durable counter materials that are also visually appealing. The key is to find a material that suits your personal style and can withstand your kitchen activities.


Consider the overall style of your kitchen and your lifestyle. If you frequently cook and use your kitchen heavily, choose a material that can withstand heat, scratches, and stains. If you're not a big cook and use your kitchen more for entertaining, you might be able to opt for a less-durable material that matches your aesthetic preference.


And if you absolutely MUST have that wood accent in that kitchen, consider a combination of counter materials, wooden cabinets or open wood shelving, to achieve a similar feel.


modern kitchen with marble counter


Professional Interior Design Insights on Kitchen Counter Material Choices

As a professional interior designer, my advice to homeowners is always to consider both aesthetics and durability when choosing a kitchen counter material. While aesthetics can set the tone and style of your kitchen, durability ensures that your kitchen remains functional and beautiful for many years to come.


Remember, a beautiful kitchen is not just about visual appeal. It's also about how well it serves its purpose. And a truly beautiful kitchen is one that remains functional, practical, and stylish, even after many years of use.


contemporary kitchen in white and walnut

Final words: Why Durability Should be a Priority in Kitchen Design

In conclusion, while butcher block may offer a unique and warm aesthetic appeal, in my opinion, its lack of durability makes it a less practical choice for kitchen counters. As a designer, I believe that durability should be a top priority in kitchen design. Not only does it ensure that your kitchen remains functional and beautiful for years, but it also provides better value for your money.


Choosing a durable counter material might mean compromising slightly on aesthetics, but the trade-off is well worth it. After all, a kitchen is a place for cooking and entertaining, and it deserves a counter material that can stand up to the task.


So, when you're planning your next kitchen design project, remember to consider not just the aesthetics, but also the durability of your counter material. It's a decision that will impact your kitchen's functionality, beauty, and overall value for many years to come.

 

Would you like to learn more about Interior Design? Or perhaps become an interior designer yourself? Follow my footsteps and study Interior Design with The Interior Design Institute where I could be your personal tutor. Click here to read more and receive a discount.



small open plan kitchen

Marieke Rijksen - Whispering Bold.jpg

Hi! Thanks for stopping by!

I am Marieke, a Dutch Australian interior designer, business executive, tutor, content creator and social media influencer.

 

I also write blogs on styling tips, makeovers, interior designs, food and Instagram insights.

Let the posts come to you.

I'll keep you posted!

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • TikTok
BW logo green no colour block_edited.png
bottom of page